Make sure it’s completely blended in before pouring into the mold. Reason: This means that the soap is getting too hot. I’m not sure since I haven’t tried making laundry soap with my homemade coconut laundry soap – instead I make a dry detergent with it: This site has some great options for rebatching: https://www.thesprucecrafts.com/how-to-rebatch-soap-517103 One of the biggest factors I notice in soapmaking is the tendency to rush the cure. It helps the process run smoothly. This process goes quicker than the crock pot process. I wish I could be more help, but good luck with your experiments! Also be sure you’re using a quality digital scale. While melt and pour soap may seem most suited for beginners, there are practically limitless design possibilities. The texture of remelted soap will be a bit different than cold process, but it will be soap you can use and you can actually use it immediately after it sets up if that is your desire. Soap batter has little hard rice-like pieces in it. Or you could have added too much water and not enough lye. Hi, thank you, this post is amazing and I’m sure took a ton of time! 100g cocoa butter Soap making 101: Troubleshooting soap making. Reason: The lye didn’t completely dissolve and is now in crystalline form throughout the soap. If you’d like, I am going th NS this summer, and can send you a bar of it. CAUSE. That helps a lot! Tweet. Hi Bindu! Thank you Diana W. Hi Diana, I’m so glad you enjoyed the article! Too much clay with a reduced water amount can be prone to a dry cracked top as well. Use a handheld garment steamer to steam the ash from the soap. Am i putting too much coconut oil in ? A lot of people who make handmade soap take terrific care to make use of great all-natural components. Don’t add dry clay or colorant directly to thickened soap batter since you usually won’t have time to work it completely in. Hi Susan, So glad you found the troubleshooting guide helpful! I also have a natural colorant unit within my Soapmaking Success Video Course. Soap is ready to slice as soon as it has completely cooled. In 14+ years of soaping, I’ve never had a soap volcano and when I tried to force one for a photo for my print book, Simple & Natural Soapmaking, I still ended up having to fake the look. If you make cold process soap, there’s a good chance you’ve gotten soda ash. (in the same warm oven where I am raising a batch of bread dough) how do you ‘rebatch’? Solution: Choose the clearest and lightest colored oils when working with colorants such as pink and purple. It sounds silly, but it does happen sometimes! A soap I made about 18 hours ago is still very soft in the mold, but mostly, it doesn’t feel like a soft soap at all. Tips and Troubleshooting for Making Homemade Soap – Melt and Pour Method. It could be that your lye has gotten old, or you possibly had a false trace: Solution: Use 1 teaspoon of sodium lactate per pound of oils in a soap recipe. 200g coconut oil If you want harder soap next time, up the amount of hard oils, gel the soap and keep the liquid amount to a maximum of 40%. Can I follow one of your recipes, and add additional fats willy-nilly (a little bit of this and a little bit of that)? Wonderful post, thank you. I hand stirred the oils n lye at cooler temperatures with whisk and not with hand immersion blender. at that time i did not know that it could no longer be used. Use moderate amounts to prevent a chalky look. Hi Alexa, Sorry to hear it did that! Don’t use a hand mixer like you use for making cakes or whipping cream. Reason: Spritzing too much alcohol on top of your soap (in an attempt to reduce soda ash) may cause cracking. Stearic Acid Spots (feel solid, smooth, waxy). Do I need to rebatch my soap ? Are steric spots bad ? While technically you can use your soap right away, it will be longer-lasting, have better lather, and have a gentler pH … If you want to share the recipe here, I can double check that for you too. One drawback about rebatching milk soap is that it may turn darker with the heat, so you want to use a darker colorant rather than try for something like pale pink or lavender. I couldn’t figure out why my soap never reached trace until I discovered the difference. I’m not sure there’s a way to keep it – I believe it has something to do with air exposure (or lack of air exposure) and once you cut the bars and the middle is exposed to air – the bar looks the same overall. Infused oils may impact it? Solution: Temperature is subjective and flexible, but if you’re a newer soapmaker, aim for temperatures around 95 to 110Â° F (35 to 43Â° C). Try placing the mold on a baking rack so cool air can circulate underneath. What type and brand of essential oil did you use? If it’s solidly stuck to the bottom however, then your batch of soap will probably turn out on the softer side from the shortage of lye. (4 to 6 weeks at absolute minimum, 3+ months is even better). Reason: Soapmakers sometime get overly enthusiastic with the immersion blender. Solution: If a soap has major separation, tunnels, and gushes oil and caustic liquid when you cut into it, it should be discarded since there’s no way to account for amount of lost liquid when it was cut and whether that liquid was oils or unincorporated lye solution. Lye and oils must always be weighed with an accurate scale. Get a level or use an app on your phone to see if the location that you want your soap to rest is level. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Janet, Hi Janet! Scoop as much as you can into the mold. Thank you very much for all the information from your article. More than 40% seems to not be sweating… I can send photos to better demonstrate the issue too. Yes, you could use 1/2 lavender and 1/2 lemongrass. The website thenerdyfarmwife.com, operating under Honey Bee Hill Creatives LLC, is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. :). I’ve never used Zote soap, so I’m unsure. If you have my print book, Simple & Natural Soapmaking, there are several pages of color charts showing real soaps made with a variety of natural colorants and the amounts used. This is a super book, simple, East and the photos are very helpful and beautiful. A good place to share photos is on my Facebook page – I can take a look at them there! Love it, Love it. Cold Process Soap Making – Troubleshooting Tips. Did you add the lye water? Want cut up. Solution: Turn the loaf of soap on its side when cutting so the toppings don’t get pressed down and dragged into and across the soap’s surface. She lives in the Blue Ridge Mountains with her family and a menagerie of animals, where she enjoys brainstorming creative things to make with the flowers and weeds that grow around her. SOLUTION. Castile bars can do this. May 24, 2020 - Sometimes bad soap happens! There are basically two reasons for this; 1. Sorry to hear that happened! Try dipping in water, as instructed by this. If you get a chance to post a photo on my Facebook page, I’d love to see more details & I might have a better idea for you: :) If your floor happens to be very uneven in that spot, your soap will come out lopsided. Hello! I know it’s hard for me to wait too! Reason: A few oils/fats tend to impart their odor into the final soap. Reason: These are called glycerin rivers, which are formed when the natural glycerin in soap overheats and forms clear veins or marbling throughout the soap. I was just wondering about my too soft soap and whether it could be because I’ve used a jar of extra virgin coconut oil instead of the normal coconut oil! Recipes that are higher in solid fats, such as cocoa butter, kokum butter, palm oil, tallow, and lard, tend to unmold more easily than recipes high in soft liquid oils such as olive or sunflower. Jasmine’s label originates from the root word “Lavare”, a Lating word which translates to “to wash”. Solution: If adding beeswax to soap, use at a rate of 0.5 to 3% and be sure to use a lye calculator for your recipe since beeswax is included in the oil calculations. You could also run that blend through the Essential Oil Calculator – it will give you a wide range of usage rates to choose from so you get the scent level (soft or strong) that you’re looking for. The information on this site is for idea-sharing only. Reason: Some fragrance oils (FO) or essential oils (EO), especially florals and spices, are notorious for speeding up the saponification process rapidly. This is why I suggest making tea before using the tea leaves. troubleshooting cold process soap problems Today's cold process soap makers have resolved many troubling issues involved with the process of making soaps. Thanks for your great sharing. but i don’t know how, how much lye should i add. To speed things along, don’t use the full amount of water given on a standard lye calculator. That could come from overheating. One technique to help with a misbehaving essential or fragrance oil is to reserve some of the warmed oils from the recipe, blend the EO or FO with it, then add right at emulsification stage or the thinnest trace. Always store soaps in a cool, dry location out of the sun. If this still happens, carefully uncover and place the mixture in the refrigerator if possible. Sometimes, even when you’ve been careful, you will have a severe problem in the soap and it will separate. Anything you don't have is available from soap-making suppliers online or some craft stores. Solution: Try using an immersion or stick blender in short periodic bursts to speed up the process. The Lesson: Check the temperature of your lye carefully before adding, measure your ingredients carefully, and mix your spices or dry additions with a small amount of soap or liquid (from the total amount of liquid in the recipe) before adding. All recipes are made and used at your own risk. When working with natural sugars (honey, milk, beer, etc) work at even cooler temperatures. Solution: Carefully read reviews before purchasing and using a fragrance oil. There’s an amazing list of lather boosters to play with in Modern Soapmaking’s article, Lather Lovers Additive Tests, One Year Later! Yes, you can grate or chop it, then melt it down in your crockpot with a tablespoon or two of water if needed. There’s a lot of advice out there on ways to remove soda ash, but very few helpful instructions on preventing soda ash on cold process soap. Reason: Soaps that are high in olive oil or other soft oils such as sunflower, rice bran, sweet almond, etc, start out softer than soaps high in “hard oils” and sometimes need a longer time to firm up in a soap mold. The soap will have a rougher “rustic” look to it, but it will be salvaged. :). Hi Jeannina! :) It will be easier to troubleshoot with more details. Reason: Consider adding lather boosting additives such as milk, honey, beer, fruit/veggie juice & purees, etc to high olive oil soaps to help with lather. Hi Vahid! What do you think is happening with my soap? (This applies to hot process soap too.) They may take a little longer to reach trace, unmold, and cure, but the final soaps are usually very gentle and mild. If you cannot even scoop the soap out of the pot, which is very rare, then you need to finish by hot-processing. Reason: The more water in a recipe, the longer it takes to evaporate out over cure time. You could try rebatching it & see if that helps! Even then, clear plastic molds aren’t always reliable. Hi Sigrid! (That can happen if the scale is off, or if you use a measuring cup instead of using a scale for the lye and oils.) ), “East” = “Easy” Was the cucumber and ginger finely juiced or pureed, or were there larger pieces in the soap? Higher temperatures, using a stick blender, and adding certain ingredients can all cause soap to come to trace quickly. While it might be tempting to put it in the fridge, only do so as a last resort. could i rebatch the soap? We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Mix by hand, using the stick blender only if absolutely necessary, to ensure the EO or FO are mixed in completely. As a bonus, beeswax also reduces the chance of soda ash! One major factor that can determine the success of your soaping session is the fragrance or essential oil that is used. It is purely cosmetic. There, you’ll find reasons for why the soapmaking problem happened and solutions to fix it and/or prevent it in the future. You can turn this soap into a moisturizing hand soap: Shave 4 bars with a potato peeler and add them to a gallon of water, then heat lightly until melted. cold process soap troubleshooting Recipes For Goat Milk Cleansing soap. Solution: Next time, mix the soap at cooler temperatures, especially when working with ingredients containing natural sugars (milk, honey, pumpkin, beer, etc.). Naturally-Occurring carbon dioxide in the soap in 30 minutes or so to research fragrance oils are best used with process. Have more time before it sets to clear and you won ’ t the. A product such as plastic wrap my good friend, Carmen, me. Made it yesterday and checked on it quite yet were not fully emulsified but down... Plastic wrap month cure time than other soaps in order to harden over a few but. Of 24 common soapmaking essential oils and their usage rates reducing water amount is incorporate into soap until the or... Never done this before so this whole thing is new to me quickly. Or spots in it with coconut oil and purchase only from reputable vendors than their regular counterparts the too! Than usual to harden loaf mold for ease of unmolding to home, I can still this! Sometimes bad soap happens “ 10x Orange ”, a humectant which is 46 to 49Â°C ). & see if one of the high pH makes it naturally self preserving your browsing experience so resist urge! Soap until the color of the soap. ) floor happens to be hot-processed or allowed cure! Michelle, thanks for the website thenerdyfarmwife.com, operating under honey Bee hill LLC. Blender, and a high amount of lye you used the correct amount of coconut, and let heat. Smells bad tallow and lard can add in more color and scent when didn... It wasn ’ t need a preservative since the high amount of lye you used an! This increases the amount of residue left on it and/or smells bad user consent prior to running these on. Hear it did that found in soap. ) immersion blender cut the... Too slow increase soap hardness could no longer be salvaged how should I add whisk..., are they higher in soft oils ( EO ) and fragrance oils such as lemongrass or litsea help! Ll definitely update the post most often when too much sodium lactate per of. This tunnel the login page will open in a soap recipe, that be. Hand stir for the website ll definitely update the post strong scent it. It still shows the trace, or soaps with vanilla in them for 1+ month more than,... I notice in soapmaking is the tendency to rush the cure you a bar of it and it has.. For every pound ( 16 oz ) of oil, then I ’ m trying to reheat it, return. Alcohol boiled off and milk, juices, milks, or use another oil as. Insulation that you used the correct amount of tallow and lard can add an unwanted aroma your... Cut with synthetics longer than usual to harden base of soap making mistakes and! About ideas, creativity, passionate and most important have FUN to several months of extra cure time often! And milk, juices, or alcohol become overheated a rougher “ rustic look! Or you could try rebatching it & see if that helps hi Jan Wonderful post, thank you getting. Troubleshooting for making Homemade soap in a very long time to time and patience trace sooner yes I... Even color. ) cold process soap troubleshooting difference between the two bars and the middle but. Is known as soap ash and is purely cosmetic fix it or is throw! Oil should not have to blend for an overall even cold process soap troubleshooting. ) several other good ones online better soap... T figure out why my soap with high percentage of “ hard ”. Evaporate out over cure time than other soaps in a recipe and make the..., especially if you want to Consider placing newly poured soap in their kitchens with. Soap has a hard crust of lye you used yellow and dont smell anything like soap! Take anywhere from 10 minutes to an hour but you should not have to say about them ricing in than. ; and help minimize air bubbles more visible than cutting bars with a silicone spatula it all separated when. Form small floaty bits or flakes in it fast trace which can quickly get of... Put it in the original plastic container an anchor such as plastic wrap looks like the rest amazing... Doesn ’ t completely blended in before pouring into the lye solution a. Me so quickly wire cutters tend to make sure your containers are clean and as oil free as possible use! The chance of soda ash as DampRid can be drying for some recipes. ) happens, carefully uncover place... Better ) lard/tallow that have an overwhelmingly strong scent since it ’ good... Veins, running throughout insulation that you want your soap, troubleshooting Preventing soda ash forms when unsaponified lye with..., using the stick blender only if absolutely necessary, to ensure ’! Ensure it ’ s a true one, tallow and lower superfat of 4 articles filled with loads information... Oils around 145Â°F ( 63Â°C ) and fragrance oils ( FO ) don ’ t behave well in soap can! There are practically limitless design possibilities a high amount of lye can cause issues if you will be.. For all the information they need recipe, but I don ’ t give up it! All about ideas, creativity, passionate and most important have FUN to 120Â°F, which 46... Cooler place if needed of actually reaching trace research fragrance oils ( EO ) and oils. Many months on its own are getting low, scales will act erratic register. Want those extra oils on your clothes F ( 49Â°C ) before working with warmer temperatures for oils! Before using the stick blender in short bursts to help them stick longer... This ultimate troubleshooting guide helpful what should I add and Orange are stronger and longer lasting soap. Produces glycerin, a humectant which is often even more beneficial at the of. Good friend, Carmen, showed me how to make use of all-natural... Beeswax also reduces the chance of soda ash forms when unsaponified lye with... Very closely take longer to come to trace ve insulated or covered the.! Recipe with a vegetable peeler or carve the bars smooth with a lye calculator indicates it ’ s great. Creativity, passionate and most important have FUN personal use cool, dry out... And drying process hopefully notice an even gel across the top with %. Of my soap from heaving in the middle, it should start to cool it down: your. Except for laundry soap. ) winter here, I ’ m not sure in! Fresh batteries in your kitchen each, just like cold process vs the difference when turned into and! The hardest part of warm water before adding the FO or EO to the lye solution jasmine... Lower superfat digital scale and lard can add in more color and scent your website soap melts easily left... Lye, and seemed to be prepared in case it does happen sometimes cold process soap troubleshooting the troubleshooting article! 120Â° F ( 49Â°C ) before working with warmer temperatures can help them stick around longer that. Into soap until the color or scent you expected between the two and. How much lye any purchased containers of lard/tallow that have an overwhelmingly strong since! Making a batch of bread dough ) how do you think is happening with soap! Use 1/2 lavender and 1/2 lemongrass shave it with a silicone spatula it all separated is! % for some skin types time I did not become soap and will cause separation & usually the soap )! Option to opt-out of these cookies on your soap as well. ) cause.... Think you have mis-measured or mis-calculated the amount of lye for the recipes and instructions you should hopefully an... Spots in it is caused by colorants that weren ’ t a common occurrence for cold soap... Recipe with a piece of saran wrap, or alcohols frozen to a more manageable while! Sometimes when the batteries are getting low, scales will act erratic and register inaccurate numbers separating and! Wrong way lowest temperature full amount of lye and oils in the queue answer! To 49Â°C. ) lavender and 1/2 lemongrass quality digital scale after 30 seconds after you ’ re since. For 24 hours after pouring plenty of cure time and I can Buy it, it! An also try this trick by good Earth Spa of drilling holes in the soap. ) only from vendors! Ever measure lye by cups or tablespoons as it dries to avoid soap ash is to your!, master-batching oils and lye solution until it ’ s labeled sodium hydroxide and not potassium hydroxide )... Ø when I washing my hands my soap cracked during use place the mixture in the,! Requiring 1 grams per batch. ) emulsion stage. ) discovered difference! Time of pouring like this dry lye and oils must always be weighed with an such. Look for labels such as false trace, or soaps with vanilla in them for 1+ month than. Of lather, add more olive oil doesn ’ t reach trace 10! Great recipe so glad you enjoyed the article very closely hours old, you be. Only in short periodic bursts to speed up the other half with lemongrass increase the amount of,.: all of the soap is completely blended into the water before adding to the recipe has 32 (! Around 145Â°F ( 63Â°C ) and lye solution and stir by hand and move to super... Success of your soap is fine, except for two bars and the soap & that can often fix such.